de•lib•er•a•tion
diˌlibəˈrāSHən/
noun
long and careful consideration or discussion.
Deliberation is a process of thoughtfully weighing options
What Is Deliberation?
The discovery of a shared direction, guided by what we value most.
Deliberation is an unbiased kind of talking that starts where the problem starts—with your experience of it. It’s not a bunch of abstract backroom negotiations, but real, genuine, human struggles of which we are a part.
Unlike debate, or lecture, or an airing of grievances, deliberation asks us to begin with what we hold most dear and share our personal experiences with a given issue. It’s not about reaching agreement or seeing eye-to-eye. It’s about looking at the costs and consequences of possible solutions to daunting problems, and finding out what we, as a people, will or will not accept as a solution.
We must listen to one another, explore the unbiased facts, test ideas, weigh options and balance tradeoffs to find where our various interests overlap—where purposes can be joined towards a shared future.
That’s where change begins.
Why Deliberate?
Studies show that the patient practice of deliberation leads to change.
Perhaps you want to do more than vote. More than sign a petition or send an email. Because you’ve realized that no one person, no single group has the answer to society’s toughest problems. Deliberation is a way to act together with your community to better understand and deal with problems more directly.
A two- to three-hour session in a thoughtful people-to-people setting, with ground rules that encourage deep dives into the facts, and a thorough examination of several possible solutions can result in clear reasons for a recommended action.
Instead of asking your leaders, “What are you going to do for me?” the question becomes, “Here are our investigations and recommendations. How will you apply these to the problem?”
Continued practice makes us stronger. The more we get together and talk, the more we establish a shared future in which we have control.
How To Deliberate?
For deliberation to succeed, deliberative groups need resources to support their efforts.
The NIF Framework is essential to the deliberative process. This framework ensures a careful, nonpartisan way of presenting alternative solutions to your group and welcoming their different views. Designed to produce a rich investigation into what your group is thinking about an issue, the Framework helps you arrive together at what it acceptable and what is not.
- The Network & The Centers for Public Life
- Forum Starter Kits block
- The NIF Issues Books
Contact the people in the NIF Network who regularly hold forums for deliberation. Ask how you can be involved as a volunteer or participant.
Resources—issue guides and starter kits here! – designed after store is done
Get your feet wet with one of our NIF Starter Kits. They include a sample issue book, a list of our publications and more. We also have Classroom Starter Kits for high school and middle school teachers.
Starter kits slider– designed after store is done
When you decide to join a forum, this is your study guide. The material in our Issue Books is not handed down from on high, but springs from the concerns of citizens. A problem is set forth with unbiased facts, useful research, and a list of various solutions. That’s where we begin.
Issue book slider– designed after store is done